Goodfella`s Pizza Italian Restaurant in Matamoras

Pizza is great. Large portions of the dinner selections. Its BYOB until liquor license is optained.

We like a lot going out. Last night we came to this delicious restaurant which friends told us about. We enjoyed a beautiful evening there with great meal and a nice team and a great chef. We put this place in our phone list and we shall surely return soon. We deeply recommend.

Absolutely horrendous all around pizza service bad!had to wait for what felt like an eternity for pizza.then we get the pizza and it nasty with a funky taste. Total waste of money.if i come back then it be with a lawyer getting sick from the pizza like my dude in the other review place ain't even for the birds

I was so disappointed..chicken parm was burnt, hard and dry. Waitress responded with" this is not a chicken patty and nobody else complained". Brought out a "Fresh" order and it was the same piece..burnt to death. My specialty pie was missing roasted red peppers and she brought a bowl of ice cold peppers. Never again

The food is always good when we go here. The service is fast and the staff is great. We love it here.

Came on Friday after a movie and food was to die for, like their sign says! The waitress was on top of her game, full room of tables and handled it like a champ with a smile on her face on her own. She was amazing!! Great staff, great food. I’ll be back! Tiffany, thank you and thank you goodfellas

Food was delicious. The portions are huuuge!

great pizza, giant slices, liquor license, great food and a friendly staff. What's not to like ? Ay-O-Ay Fugetaboutit !

1st time goers and we ordered a large stuffed pizza. Omgosh!!!! The best pizza I've EVER had!!!! We are in the area for 5 months and we will definitely be back!!!

Had the best time. Here love all the Goodfellas references. I am a big fan of the movies and history of a Goodfella. Thank guys y'all truely great. I am writing this review while sitting in this very amazing restaurant

The staff are always friendly. The pizza never disappoints. The calzones are to die for.My favorite pizza place.

The pizzas are huge and delicious. If your a pizza lover this is the place for you. Don't forget to get the punch out card. That way everytime you purchase a pizza you get a hole punch. On the 10th one you get a free pie. Also on Monday and Tuesday it's only $10 for a large pie. Definitely worth it. Don't miss out. This Place rocks! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

I should have known, started with sitting down and hearing rap and country on the speakers. The staff were very polite and pleasant. The appetizer , onion rings came out burnt. My chicken parmigiana also came out burnt. My girlfriends baked ziti was pasta on a plate with a reddish cream sauce with no taste. The red sauce had no flavor also, very bland. One helpful employee was running around in and out of the kitchen with her flip flops on. Not going back, plenty of other places to eat.

Great place, nice people, awesome food. Best I've had in the pocono area. I'm a new yorker... so we know our pizza!

Really nice place, and amazing pizza. Love it!

Excellent pizza. The right amount of cheese and sauce along with a crispy crust. Delicious! Quick and friendly service.

Stopped here for lunch on the way through. Food and service were both awesome!

I stopped in for pizza an hour before they said they would close and didn't have any slices with pepperoni, so instead of saying no problem we will make it they said they were closing so I had to buy what they had made! Which was sitting there all day! I would have paid for a whole pie but they just wanted to close up! I would never go there again!

Took all grandkids and moms and dads there after movie. They are very family friendly and excellent waitress. We will definitely go again.

Old pizza tasted really bad

On point. Pizza was very well made not soggie or burnt.. size was what one wants to pay for but rarely receives

The food would really good what I had I had French fried with gravy Chicken Parmesan I was Full The price with good I was happy.

Wanted to get chicken parmigiana. Only had French dressing for salad. Only had coke and Diet Coke. Out of stock on everything else. Asked if they had bottled water or something without so much sugar and was told all they had was coke, Diet Coke, and beer!! I understand that with the COVID scare business is down, But a bottle of salad dressing costs around $3!!! I immediately left because if the owner doesn’t have enough common sense to keep popular items in stock, it means what variety he has left is probably out of date!!Will never stop again!

Amazing food!

Really good pizza 🍕.

Food was delicious! Ordered a calzone, penne ala vodka and garlic bread and it was a bang for our buck! Our server Tiffany was great, she really cared about our experience there. I will be back ! Thanks goodfellas family!

Me, the wife and my 2 kids all got sick after leaving,i puked in the parking lot. The rest of the family with non stop runs. Pizza (sicilian) was cold, like thrown in the oven real quick then out, wasnt really busy and dough was still raw. Fried foods took forever to come out and seemed like it's been awhile since they changed the oil in there fryer. I get it, it's a pizza place, was convenient since we had just left the movies next door, but for someone who's profession is culinary arts, I will never be back here again.

I am a local resident and just tried this place 2 months ago. Im obsessed! Delicious pizza. Fast service. And clean. Highly recommended

This was a pretty good find on my way to visit Michael Scott and Dwight Schrute in Scranton.

Ribs were fantastic! Generous pour at the bar, and great service! As someone who has traveled the country eating and drinking, this place is special. Say hi to Carl, he'll treat you right. ;)

I had pizza and garlic knots both where really good. They had a decent amount of beer as well. Are server was fast and very nice. They had good daily special deals as well.

Was just driving around . Stopped in for a slice of pizza. Enjoyed it so much has to take a pie back to Orange County .

Great food great services but very cold they need turn up the heat

A really good pizza! Staff very friendly. Always clean!

Came in last night since I’ve been staying at Hampton inn for work and I was surprised how good the food and service was for the area.. my waitress was amazing, very sweet young girl with black hair.. the food was amazing definitely some real New York pizza and Italian food! Whenever I’m back in the area I’ll know where to stop.

Great pizza and service.

Supersizes Slices are $5, $1 for each topping.

Pizza to DIE for! Excellent pizza and very friendly. Enjoyed the outside seating. We would definitely go back.

Awesome food and staff no complaints. Can't figure why some ppl think otherwise maybe they're never happy

We ordered at the counter and told the staff we were sitting to eat but wanted to get the slices going we were in a hurry. I had to get up and ask for anything we needed. The girl working dropped our food off and we never spoken to again. The food was delicious though.

I love the food there

do not order online because when they messed up my order they said there was nothing they could do to fix my order I will not be giving them my business again

Very good pizza! Never had a bad pizza or app here. Waitstaff very nice and friendly. They even made a specialized pizza that was not on the menu when asked. Best pizza in the tri-state.

My boys love to eat here, we come every chance we get!

Great food, great prices and great service

I've been here twice. I had a good time both times. The staff is nice. The waitress even offered to cut up my son's pizza slice because hes 2. No big deal but thoughtful. The food is very good. I got a meatball parm "coffin" the first time and just wings the second. My wife got the tortellini both times because she was so impressed by it. The sell booze too and its a decent selection. We sat outside and even though its a strip mall, its nice. They have a fence and you don't feel like you're in a parking lot.

Two stars because the Sicilian pizza was good. Ordered the Tiramisu to go for desert and found mold spores on top. Needless to say, spoiled the whole meal..

I wanted to grab a something quick and i have been wanting to try something new. So i went in and ordered four slices to go. Two cheese and two meat lovers. Each slice was like three regular slices. The service and the food was fantastic. I could only make it through two of their slices before i was full. It was awesome to say the least. I will definitely return to try some of the other items on their menu